FIXME **This page is not fully translated, yet. Please help completing the translation.**\\ //(remove this paragraph once the translation is finished)//

====== edu-ID - Levels of Assurance ======
~~NOTOC~~
(back to [[de:aai:eduid:start|Overview]])
{{INLINETOC 2}}

\\
FIXME Can the concept of attribute quality be adopted 1:1 from SWITCH? See [[https://www.switch.ch/edu-id/docs/services/attributes/quality-levels/|Attribute Quality]]

**Attribute**
  * see [[de:aai:eduid:vc_2020-12-11#attribute|Meeting from 11.12.2020]]
  * Profile?

**Identity Proof**
  * FIXME - Are LoAs needed that say something about this?
  * See also [[de:aai:eduid:ag5|Working group Identity Proof]]
  
===== Sandbox =====
**References:**
  * [[https://wiki.refeds.org/display/ASS/REFEDS+Assurance+Framework+ver+1.0|REFEDS Assurance Framework (RAF)]]
  * [[https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/DE/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32015R1502&from=EN|eIDAS Implementing Regulation]]
  * [[de:aai:assurance|DFN-AAI - Identity Assurance]]

\\

^Identity verification etc.  ^RAF  ^eIDAS ^DFN-AAI ^edu-ID  ^
| RAF: \\ 1. Identity proofing and credential issuance, \\ 2. renewal and replacement \\ eIDAS: 2.1.2, 2.2.2, 2.2.4  | /IAP/low | -- | Basic (only 1.) | Placeholder 1 |  
| ::: | /IAP/medium | low | Advanced (only 1.) | Placeholder 2 |
| ::: | /IAP/high | substantial | -- | Placeholder 3 |
| ::: | -- | high | -- | Placeholder 4 |

**Important question: Can we assume that the quality of the identity determination is proportional to the quality of the attributes derived from the respective identity source? If yes, then so(?):** 

^Attribute/identity sources ^Proposal categorization ^Comments ^
| self-asserted | Placeholder 0 | -- |
| Challenge-Response | Placeholder 1 | Analog DFN-AAI Basic | 
| eID (eIDAS) - eID server (clients: ID card app, card reader, etc.) | Placeholder 2-4 | If eIDAS LoA is known(?) |
| eID (eIDAS) - other module confirmations (e.g. Post Ident) | Placeholder 2 | LoA not known - eIDAS low must be accepted |
| Home institution (DFN-AAI) | Placeholder 1-2 | DFN-AAI Basic or Advanced |
| Other - ORCID | Placeholder 1| API + User Login |
| Other ... (others to be expected) | depending on the method used for linking |